The Strange Case Of Michael Caputo
(X-posted at TAP)
This story just keeps getting weirder and weirder. It starts about 24 hours after Andrew Cuomo released his report on L'affaire Bruno. Bouldin remembers it like this:
The first Spitzer-bashing email from Michael Caputo's NYFacts.net went out on July 10th, 2007, at 12:41 PM Eastern. Since then, the group has sent out 35 further emails. Another site, Spitzerfile.com, which interestingly only loads through a redirect from NYFacts.net, went live sometime after July 10th, and has also been sending out emails.
NYFacts.net even briefly branched out into Obama-bashing on August 8th, with an email entitled "Obama pulls from all-white Harmonie Club', which contained a piece by Maggie Haberman in the Murdoch Post.
Both Bouldin and I were both on this email list as were pretty much every media outlet in the state. It was one hell of a list and it was apparently assembled in record time. what was interesting was not so much who those emails were going to but the addresses that were being used. Some folks were getting those emails at addresses they hadn't used in years, others at brand new ones. Some people were getting them at purely personal addresses.
You ain't seen nothing yet. MUCH more weirdness on the flip...
But this story only gets curiouser and curiouser. Like the rampant speculation that Caputo is working for Bruno consultant, original Watergate CREEP critter, senior official on Bob Dole's 1996 campaign for president, 2000 Miami Mobster and general all around Super Freak, Roger Stone. Caputo denies that he is working with or for Stone, though they have a long history of collaboration. Here's but one example:
Two vendors for a current campaign assisted by Stone—the senate campaign of Larry Klayman—also donated in Florida, with public relations consultant Michael Caputo and Tasmania Productions owner Teddi Segal donating $250 (she says she doesn't know Stone). Caputo, ironically, was Stone's spokesman in 1996, when Stone was embroiled in the most embarrassing scandal of his career—the much ballyhooed revelation that he and his wife had advertised, with photos, for swinging partners in magazines and on the Internet. Caputo has, until recently, been handling press inquiries for Klayman, an evangelical who led the sex assault in Washington on Bill Clinton and is running a moral-majority, retake-Cuba campaign for senate.
Caputo says he's not working with Stone and "never worked in New York politics at Roger Stone's behest", but Robert A. George, a reporter for the New York Post asks this question on his personal blog:
I should make another obvious point: If Stone and Caputo aren't working together in some fashion, how did both of my accounts end up on Caputo's mailing list. I've never previously received e-mails -- to any of my accounts -- from Michael Caputo. On the other hand, as noted above, I have gotten them from Roger Stone.
Next we learn that Caputo has a myserious "anonymous benefactor" with a penchant for videography.
Michael Caputo, the man behind the Troopergate news-alert service NYFacts.net, today sent out an e-mail from another of his anti-Spitzer sites, Spitzerfile.com, with a subject line that read: "See Eliot Spitzer's meltdown."
On the site is a video of the July 26 Capitol Red Room bill signing ceremony at which The Post's Fred Dicker badgered the governor for refusing to answer his questions about the scandal.
The Politicker's Azi Paybarah was present that day and videotaped the back-and-forth, but he tells me he didn't provide the tape to Caputo, which raises the question: So who did? And, perhaps more importantly, why?
Caputo has repeatedly insisted that he's working independently and not in conjunction with the Senate GOP's consultant Roger Stone, with whom Caputo has a longstanding relationship. Reached in Florida, Caputo professed to have no idea who provided him with the footage, saying it was FedExed to his Buffalo office in the form of a DVD.
"The return address was some Hanna Barbara name, clearly something made up," Caputo said. "It came to me from a New York City FedEx office.
When it was pointed out that Stone keeps an apartment in the city, Caputo replied that he hasn't spoken to Stone in some time, but added:
"To tell you the truth, if Roger wanted to send me something, he would just send it."
Caputo again insisted that he is running NYFacts.net and Spitzerfile.com out of the goodness of his own heart and is not on anyone's payroll. He said he's having "a blast" with his "labor of love," and expects there's a lot more where this came from.
So, Michael Caputo, who isn't working with Roger Stone, the man Bruno is paying to preserve his Senate Majority at all costs, though they have worked extensively in the past and is now getting video of the governor, shot on scene at the governor's press conference in a package sent from NYC with a cartoon character's name in the return address slot. OK. Well, at least he's "having a blast", right?
Well, it's amazing what 12 hours or so can do. Apparently, his "labor of love" that was so much fun yesterday afternoon, has turned into something much darker. He now claims that he's being "attacked" and that his family is being threatened "from the Democratic side of the aisle."
Spitzer's Attacker Claims He's Being Threatened
Michael Caputo, a Republican operative who has been circulating unflattering news stories about Eliot Spitzer to reporters, said this morning that Democrats are attacking him and threatening his family.
“They made very clear threats to me and my family in New York City,†Caputo said in a radio interview with WROW. “I’m getting abused and threatened. Harassing someone who is just trying to be an active conservative is just silly.â€
Caputo declined to specifically characterize the nature of the threats or say who they were coming from.
He added “I’m fairly certainly this is coming from the Democratic side of the aisle.â€
So, today he's being "threatened" and "abused", though he won't say how or by whom.
Can this story get any weirder? I have a feeling that it most certainly will.
Stay tuned.
Dirty Tricks

Response From Michael Caputo
Look, folks - I am not being paid. Not by Sen. Bruno, not by Roger Stone, not by anyone. I am just a conservative activist and I take orders - and money - from nobody on this.
Unfortunately, I have nobody taking orders from me on this, either. I'm doing it all myself. If I can do it, any dope can - but it does take some time out of my day.
Honest to God, I wouldn't know Sen. Bruno if he boarded my boat. But I graduated from SUNY, I've been in the arena nearly 30 years, I read the news, and I have computers. So why is it so impossible for the media and bloggers to believe I can handle NYFacts and SpitzerFile on my own?
I'm normally thick-skinned, but even I'm starting to get a bit offended here. Fess up: do you think I'm just too stupid to pull this off?
Remember, the guy who's writing the script for me is Richard Milhous Spitzer. He authored this tragicomedy; he created his own starring role.
What's more funny: the insinuation that I got the DVD from Stone because it came from New York City. Last I looked, there were a few people living there directly affected by Spitzer's capricious, thug-like behavior. Maybe millions?
With all the people AG Spitzer screwed in the business community - entire industries - can't you imagine a groundswell of folks out there eager to see him pay for his crimes? Well, those people are on my email list and many are in New York City.
If you could only see my email inbox everyday, chirping all day long with unsolicited incoming information. The DVD was certainly not the first thing I received via Internet, snail and express mail. Is that a shock to all of you?
Importantly, I was threatened; I don't feel threatened. I've been around the block a few times. I've worked in boardrooms, on battlefields, in Belarus. I've been spat upon, beaten, shot, and stabbed. I don't scare all that easily anymore and I am certainly not afraid of this sophmoric attempt to silence me.
What Azi Paybarah's story didn't tell you about our discussion on Fred Dicker's radio show: my Internet servers endured 50-plus hours of a "denial of service" attack. It didn't take much to unwind, but it was coming from central New York. You also missed how I was threatened: via telephone, as hundreds of phone-bank calls flooded my cellphone. The calls came from Morris Plains, New Jersey.
This is likely more thug-like behavior from Spitzer cronies. Tired of being hammered with the truth, they decided to shut me down. Well, it failed.
But I do have some PR101 advice for the Dems: read the Constitution, leave me be, and do a little communicating yourselves. Develop and rent grasstops email lists. Set up Web sites, send out targeted emails. (HINT: don't just focus on reporter emails, that gets you very low ROI.)
Heck, you might even find a few mystery packages arriving to your office, too. Last week, my parrot received a chew toy via US Mail from an "anonymous benefactor" in Albany. (Augie says thanks; she's ecstatic.) Someone sent me a nice bottle of New York State wine via DHL, too. (Thanks "Pete"; I drank it the other night with a nice red snapper I caught just an hour before.)
One thing is clear for the Dems: you cannot just use the Albany Times Union as your press office anymore.
Because the word is out on Spitzer. And times have changed. So deal with it.
Michael Caputo

simple answers to simple questions
I'm normally thick-skinned, but even I'm starting to get a bit offended here. Fess up: do you think I'm just too stupid to pull this off?
It's the great question of our time: are conservatives deceitful misanthropes, or are they simply stupid? From Iraq to New Orleans to bit players pissing up-stream in New York, it's usually nearly impossible to prove which it is, and at a certain point it's not really worthwhile to invest the time to figure out which one it happens to be.
Hello
First off, welcome. Nice you stopped by to comment. Don't complain about any delay in posting because we also are a small operation and if you aren't willing to register, you have to wait until an editor (generally Bouldin, I believe) approves the comment. You are welcome to register here at which point you don't have to wait for moderation.
Now, to the point. From my point of view it doesn't matter if you are working for Bruno for pay or not, though not sure what the legal ramifications would be if any.
What is important to me is that you are pushing the agenda of a political party that has proven itself to be corrupt, morally bankrupt and a great disaster for this state and this nation. People are sick of what the Republicans did with our country since Bush too office, and though NY Republicans show somewhat more sanity than Republicans do nationally, NY State under Pataki and Bruno (with no real help I admit from Silver) was run like crap. Their little triumvirate did nothing for your average New Yorker.
People want change. Bruno can't stand change because it spoils his little party (small "p"...metaphorical, of course). So rather than standing up to Spitzer like a man, he is trying to smear Spitzer. Typical of the Republican tactics that, ultimately, are killing the Republican party. Almost as bad as the completely fabricated Whitewater fiasco.
Is Spitzer the man to bring change? Well, not really sure about that. He hasn't yet convinced me he is good in his own right, rather than merely being better than the Pataki-Bruno-Silver triumvirate. What I would really like to see is a more functional legislature, not rule by Spitzer decree. But lacking a legislature that is willing to clean up its act, I'd rather Spitzer steamrolling the legislature than the dysfunctional crap that the triumvarite gave us. So unless Bruno is willing to start cleaning things up (fat chance!) maybe he better step aside.
Registered
I didn't realize the delays associated with guest posts; thanks for clearing that up. I'll stay better connected next time around.
And, by the way - you will get no argument from me on the fate of national Republicans. I could write a book about it, but it bores me to tears. After working for Jack Kemp in the '80s, I worked for Bush '41. Today, I have intense and specific criticism for Bush '43. And the so-called religious right - don't get me started.
In contrast, I think the Empire State GOP is in good hands, particularly because the religious right is not as pronounced in New York. I was delighted to move home and get involved again. My email flyers were supposed to be a way for me to step into the arena, solo. I had no idea I'd become the fray - but that's okay.
I think Sen. Bruno will step up. That, I know, is a point where we disagree. From where I sit, a more functional government would demand the Governor come clean. Meanwhile, I'll stay focused on Richard Milhous Spitzer.
Best wishes,
MC
Again welcome
Expect a bumpy ride, but that's politics. I was surprised when we became part of the center of the NY-11 Democratic Primary fight. We weathered it. Be interesting to watch your situation develop. Will say that Bruno will be hard to sell to most people. In fact, the State Senate in general will be hard to sell to people. Was happy to see Eric Adams get in, but I figure he'll need some help to stir things up.
And Spitzer...well, Albany may well need a good rumble. Will Spitzer or Bruno land the knock out blow or will they take eachother down, leaving the arena open to...?

Where's my post?
Guys, I entered a lengthy response to this story and it never posted. Also, please don't post a quotation of me saying "I'm fairly certainly..." because I don't speak like a moron.
[Ed. note]: Comments by users without a registered account are manually approved, which usually happens once a day, first thing in the morning.















One of the Caputo e-mails
One of the Caputo e-mails was an Op-Ed attacking Spitzer as anti-Black from Alton Maddox. Maddox is the disbarred lawyer who was Al Sharpton's accomplish in the Tawana Brawley scam. Maddox' most notorious moments was when he declared that former AG Robert Abrams had masturbated to photos of Brawley. It might seem strange that an "conservative" like Caputo would circulate something by a Black radical but keep in mind that both Caputo & Stone helped Rev. Al in his Presidential campaign.