Who is Cesar Borja Jr. and Why Does He Matter?

I am not an enthusiastic fan of Hillary Clinton for a variety of reasons. However, her dogged dedication to a cause very close to my heart is enough to earn my vote. Hillary continues to champion the cause of the tens of thousands of victims of 9/11--no, not those who died in the attack but those who died and are dying and will die as a result of the attack.

Hillary invited the son of Cesar Borja to the State of the Union Address in her seemingly futile crusade to focus national attention on what one day may be considered to be one of the most heinous crimes in American history. Cesar Borja is one of a growing number of 9/11 heroes who are dying. Borja needs a lung transplant because he was poisoned on The Pile. Borja is one of as many as 400,000 victims of the largest and most ignored toxic waste dump in world history.

Back in September of 2006, NY1 ran a series on the release of a Mount Sinai Medical Center study that horrifyingly documented the true nightmare and crime of 9/11. This profoundly disturbing study scientifically documents the short and long term health impact of the World Trade Center collapse among an estimated 400,000 New Yorkers. That number includes those heroes who worked on the pile during the days and weeks following 9/11, the office workers and residents who returned to their jobs and homes in lower Manhattan within weeks following the disaster and residents of Brooklyn and Staten Island who were subsequently exposed to lingering dust and the dumping of debris.

The evidence is clear, overwhelming, "statistically significant and conclusive" and the questions raised by the evidence are likely the most disturbing and spirit-crushing questions ever raised in American history.

9/11 produced the most lethal and overwhelming toxic waste dump crisis in human memory. Close to 400,000 men, women and children were exposed to unprecedented toxic doses of dozens of known carcinogens, toxins and pathogens.

Of those exposed most were exposed not because of the attack but because the Bush Administration, the Giuliani administration and Christine Todd Whitman, the then head of the environmental protection agency declared that it was safe to return to lower Manhattan; and they did so because they determined that the financial, commercial and real estate interests of the city, state and nation took precedence over the lives of tens of thousands of human beings.

In fact, when Christine Todd Whitman told New Yorkers on September 18, 2001 that the air in Lower Manhattan was "safe to breath" she was not only lying, she was knowingly condemning hundreds of thousands of people to an early grave. One of the panelists on NY1 said it simply enough: Christine Todd Whitman will be responsible for more 9/11 deaths than Osama bin Laden. Whitman, Bush and Giuliani buried the facts that were handed to them by the experts: the air was lethal and would remain so for quite some time to come. Some suggest that it is still unbreathable in certain areas of downtown Manhattan through today, some five years later.
It is conceivable that George W. Bush, Christine Todd Whitman and Rudy Giuliani will be judged by history as among the greatest mass murderers of all time. But within our time they will live as heroes and champions among millions of Americans. And Rudy Giuliani's punishment for betraying the people of New York is Republican support for a run at the White House.

It's interesting to note that some months ago Whitman actually launched a campaign to blame Giuliani for "mass murder" and Giuliani has launched a campaign to blame Whitman. It appears that faced with the Mount Sinai report neither side is denying it's obvious veracity, rather they are fighting to assign blame. Of course the media, the criminal justice system and the American public remain indifferent to this blame game and to this nightmare. If you google hard, you'll find the stories, but overall, the media serves its corporate masters well.

Hillary continues to champion this cause--albeit in her very low key and polite manner. And in the meantime, the media remains indifferent. That is what most shocks me. Is it because the crime and the scope of this horror is so great that no one dare face it? Is the question just too awful to ask or to answer? The facts very much indicate that Bush, Pataki, Whitman and Giuliani knowingly condemned men like Cesar Borja to death and knowingly condemned tens of thousands of lower Manhattan and Brooklyn residents to an early grave. Why is the issue met with such silence? Why was the presence of Cesar Borja Jr. at the State of the Union address a minor footnote?

Richard Rothstein's picture

| | | | | | |

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Bouldin's picture

That's not enough

Kudos to Hillary for working on this; same to Chuck, Nadler, Weiner and all the others who have worked on it. But the gravity of the issue - you're entirely correct when you say that Todd-Whitmann will be responsible for more 9/11 deaths than Osama - requires not the softly modulated tones we're seeing, but something frankly more appropriate and more aggressive.

Daniel Millstone's picture

Well, my reading of the EPA/NYC

reports about ground zero do not suggest to me that either Guiliani or Todd Whitman knew specific facts about air quality that add up to " knowingly condemning" anyone to death. Air sampling is very difficult to do and analysis of air samples sometimes pruduces results which, while reassuring, are not representative or reliable.

The strongest statement I think might be shown is that both NYC and EPA were willfully blind to the limits of their sampling and analysis. As you may know, it's very hard to pin the tail on the donkey -- to prove that a later illness was caused by an earlier exposure.

By not compelling ground zero workers to wear serious respiratory protective gear (which after all is a pain to use) NYC & EPA allowed ground zero workers to be exposed to a chemical soup.

By not getting good samples, EPA & NYC have made it difficult to trace any illness back to any exposure.

I think that reassuring noises that EPA and NYC made about air quality may have been a sort of whistling in the dark, but not data-based, optimism.

If you know facts that add up to stronger case, tell me.

Anonymous Coward's picture

Cesar Borja and President Bush

I think this whole Borja-Bush episode is perhaps the most transparent attempt to elicit insincere sympathy.

Bush wants to help his sagging ratings (fat chance).

Borja is an opportunist; he sees a chance and decides to take advantage

I am truly sorry about Borja's father, but I am also truly sorry about the 3000 people who died and the hundreds of others who are living with residual 9/11 complications.

Borja says that "he told President Bush to come to New York so that they can talk." Talk about arrogance !

brought to you by


Current weather

NY - New York City, Central Park

night-overcast
  • Overcast
  • Temperature: 37.4 °F
  • Wind: West, 6.9 mph
  • Pressure: 29.21 inHg
  • Rel. Humidity: 87%
  • Visibility: 6 miles

Premium Advertisers


Fill up our coffee cup fund!






Visit Our Sponsors


Subscribe to our daily digest

In keeping with the "city that never sleeps" tradition, keep up to date with our daily syndication digest.



Powered by FeedBlitz


culturekitchen Media

The Publisher
Liza Sabater

Fresh dissent served daily
culturekitchen

Grassroots News and
Activism for New Yorkers

Daily Gotham

Feminist Bloggers Network
BlogSheroes

A new kind of voyeurism
Voogling

Art + Code + Philosophy
Potatoland.blog

Got any dirt, tips, leads or money for us? Then drop us a line or two at editors [at] dailygotham [dot] com or use our general contact form to reach everybody in the editorial team ASAP.


Only in New York

"The greatest anti-poverty movement in American history is the organized labor movement."

Who's online

There are currently 4 users and 1307 guests online.

Blogroll

Editors and Contributors

Mole's Progressive Democrat
Alien and Sedition
Dan Jacoby

The Indies

Adirondack Musings
The Albany Project
Angry Brown Butch
Atlantic Yards Report
Blue Spot
Buffalo Pundit
Buffalo Geek
Bike Blog
Brooklyn Rail
The Community Alliance
Danger Democrat
DDDB
DragonFlyEye
EverythingNY
Gowanus Lounge
Hell's Kitchen Online
Joshing Politics
Mamita Mala
Mamapalooza blog
More Gardens
Nassau GOP Watch
New York Games
No Land Grab
NY 13
On NY Turf
Peter King Watch
Politics on the Hudson
Open Orleans
Prometheus6
Room Eight
Steve Gilliard RIP
The Oil Drum
Troy Polloi
Rochester Turning
Simply Left Behind
Time's Up
The Working Families Party Man
Power from Truth by Chris Owens

The little big media

Capitol Confidential
Gotham Gazette
Daily Politics
Wonkster
New York Blade
NYC Bloggers
NYC Indymedia
The Politicker
EmpireZone
Power Plays
Spin Cycle

The big little media

Curbed
Gawker
Gothamist
The Politico
City Limits

Everybody Party! blogs

New Democratic Majority
Stonewall Democrats
Working Families Party's WFPBlog

The Brains

The Brennan Center
Reform NY
The Century Foundation
Center for American Progress
Drum Major Institute's DMIblog
edwize
TortDeform

The Movement

New Democratic Majority
Democracy for NYC
DL21C
Act Now
Capitol D Group
New York Democratic Lawyers Council

The Loyal Opposition

Alarming News
News Copy
Ragged Thots
Suitably Flip
Urban Elephants
Serf City

Fun Stuff

City Rag
Jossip
Overheard in New York
Cobalt 6

This list is a work in progress. Are there blogs you believe should be included (maybe your own)? Please leaves us a message through our contact page. Or drop us a line at :

editors(at)
dailygotham(dot)com


Progressive Districts

Progressive States

Alabama
Arizona
California Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
Florida
Georgia
Hawaii
Idaho
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
Minnesota
Mississippi
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
New York
North Carolina
North Dakota
Ohio
Ohio
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
South Dakota
Tennessee
Texas
Texas
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington
West Virginia
Wisconsin
Pacific Northwest
Sunbelt